The Motion Picture Sound Editors (MPSE) has announced that projects where Generative AI is used to create elements for the final soundtrack will not be eligible for the organization’s Golden Reel Awards.
A statement from MPSE read in part that it has “always promoted and will continue to value the human endeavor of artistic creation. Our Golden Reel Award honors people who utilize their skills and artistry to push the boundaries of storytelling through sound.
“We support and prize technological advances that assist artists in their creations. However, standards for the legal and ethical use of Generative AI have yet to be established and are far from being accepted broadly. What we choose to promote as award-worthy points to how much we value the human endeavor of artistic creation.”
Due to these concerns and an organizational mission to uphold and celebrate the creative human endeavor of sound and music editorial, sound design, and Foley artistry, the MPSE will not accept Generative AI projects for Golden Reel Award consideration. Golden Reel Award qualification rules are being updated and will be published on the MPSE website soon.
At the same time, the MPSE is keeping an open mind regarding the situation. As the industry evolves to adopt tools and techniques, current or yet to be developed, the MPSE board of directors and AI committee are poised to evolve their stance on this issue, ensuring we adhere to our mission. The MPSE remain opens to what the technological future may bring in support of the humans working in the craft of sound editorial.
David Barber, MPSE president, stated, “It is an enormous question to ask: how much of our humanity are we willing to give away to technology, especially in the arts? The time to ponder that question, set up boundaries, and guide how AI is assimilated into our workflow and lives was yesterday. The dam of AI has broken, and the waters are upon us. Choosing what we embrace as award-worthy filmmaking is a way of diverting those waters while we grapple with this exponential change. As AI technology infiltrates and permeates our industry, rules and accepted practices for its use need to emerge that keep artists at the forefront.”